In Australia a lot of healthcare and places are now starting to use ASAB to get around respecting your gender. I absolutely loathe ASAB, because it’s even more bioessentialist than AGAB.
I much prefer the organ inventory approach, which also helps cis people too, e.x. hysterectemies.
Organ Inventory > Sex at Birth > Gender, in a medical context.
Ideally you have all three because all are medically relevant (self-explanatory, chromosomes, and hormones, in that order - all medically relevant), but good luck passing legislation to put all three on an ID, not to mention the dangers (in many places of the world) of having “Hello I am sex or gender non-conforming” on your ID everywhere you go.
No, “sex at birth” is not a meaningful category, and institutions collecting such data opens up new vectors for worse outcomes while also being extremely disrespectful towards patients.
In Australia a lot of healthcare and places are now starting to use ASAB to get around respecting your gender. I absolutely loathe ASAB, because it’s even more bioessentialist than AGAB.
I much prefer the organ inventory approach, which also helps cis people too, e.x. hysterectemies.
Organ Inventory > Sex at Birth > Gender, in a medical context.
Ideally you have all three because all are medically relevant (self-explanatory, chromosomes, and hormones, in that order - all medically relevant), but good luck passing legislation to put all three on an ID, not to mention the dangers (in many places of the world) of having “Hello I am sex or gender non-conforming” on your ID everywhere you go.
No, “sex at birth” is not a meaningful category, and institutions collecting such data opens up new vectors for worse outcomes while also being extremely disrespectful towards patients.
Completely disagree based on my understanding of modern medicine, so I hope you can understand my reluctance to trust the word of a random stranger.
Completely agree, which is why I already said as much in the comment you replied to.