cross-posted from: https://feddit.online/c/tech@feddit.online/p/2115005/italy-fines-meta-eur805m-for-accessing-android-users-photos-and-videos
/me looking smug for never having installed any of the social media’s app in my phone (exactly because I did NOT trust them in any way form or shape) and back when I still had it always using the browser interface.
I like how every other tech news story that comes out these days is just, “Here’s more proof every single paranoid schizophrenic was actually right.”
I guess this is why GrapheneOS has a separate layer to only allow apps to see your photos on per-image basis. It’s to stop Zucc from scraping your noodz. The bloody pervert.
Did you read the article? The issue was regarding how the app requested for access. If you don’t give it access, it won’t see your photos. The per-image thing is also on base android, it’s not a graphene only feature.
but the truth has never stopped the graphene folks from wanking on about how superior graphene is.
As a Graphene user I take offence at this. Like, did you know that Graphene - and only Graphene - sorts your text messages into conversations? And the touch driver uses something called ‘multitouch’ so you can interact with UI elements using intuitive tap, pinch and swipe gestures? And the screen supports literally thousands - thousands - of colours? Honestly you plebs on your stock Andumdumroids and iToys don’t know what you’re missing out on.
Android doesn’t have that by default? I had a Pixel for years, but it was only a work phone so I literally just used it for three apps. I put GrapheneOS on it since I’m no longer employed, and it’s okay. I didn’t think the per-app limitation was a GrapheneOS thing.
It works the same way on iOS, except obviously for Apple’s own stuff because they’re special and have privileged access. Stupid garbage.
Android has multiple permissions options. Apps can request access via the file picker (always gives restricted access to only the files or folders the user selects) or full gallery access / all files access. The latter are only supposed to be used by stuff like photo apps and similar tools.
Google also has their “SafetyCore” thing that they forced-installed to scrape and catalog every photo on the device.
€805M is probably less than they would have had to pay all the users for unrestricted free use of the content to train AI so that’s a bargain.
That’s probably less than the legal expenses for the case.
Honestly they should fine them hundreds of billions of euros
They probably burnt a couple more million on their lawyers fees to fight this too. That’s something I guess
Realistically, they’re large enough to have a dedicated legal team. Like the lawyers probably work directly for Meta, so they’d be paid regardless of whether or not they are actively litigating cases. At the very least, they’ll keep the lawyers on retainer.
in style of hobbits wanting second breakfast
“Yeah. But what about the prison time?”
Excellent news and well done. More, please. I also love how the journalist included this line:
The amount is about 0.47% of the group’s global revenue.
Again: More, please.
What about their Italy revenue?
I wonder how much they accumulate globally on fines. There has been a lot recently.
It’s a bigger share of their profits though, maybe almost 1%. 😋
In this day and age of funny accounting, I’m surprised they even have an accounting profit.
Maybe it’s all strangelly ending in some holding company based in the Cayman Islands but registered in the Republic Of Ireland (to take advantage of Ireland’s wonderful and absolutelly-not-created-on-purpose-by-that-country scheme for tax avoidance), a company which just so happens to get paid every single cent of the parent company’s profits for “use of trademark” so all its profits are “taxed” by a country with 0% corporate tax?! Do they still do the Dutch Sandwish or there’s a new more fashionable scheme now?
It’s a good start. Let’s keep moving.
Oh look, one of Meta’s apps doing invasion of privacy things behind the user’s back even though Meta said it wouldn’t do that. Again.
They’ve been doing shit like that for decades now. Fines clearly don’t work and they cannot be trusted to not break the law again. At that point Meta should be declared a criminal organization and dealt with accordingly.
Seriously, the world wouldn’t miss anything if Meta disappeared.
Until the fines don’t start really hurting them (i’m talking about billions, not millions), this will just be an operational cost to account for when they do it.
Or better: start putting people in jail. The moment a CEO sees they can actually go to jail, we’ll start seeing all these companies fall in line.
This is more the government making them pay some taxes with an excuse, than a punishment. When you have that much money you’re above the law, if they try too punish them, they will just buy everyone needed to avoid it.
Companies this big shouldn’t exist.
Idk… 805 mil is oretty close to a bil
Fines are summing up, it’s hard to keep growing their userbase these days, and they have been making a lot of bad investments. Their grounds might be already unstable
Yeah but the execs can just declare bankrupcy and make a new company with all the money they made. So that’s hardly a problem.
Welcome to capitalism.
That doesn’t make this pointless, each one of these is a scratch, but enough scratches will kill even a monster like Facebook
How many lawsuits have drawn blood from them just the year? It feels like it’s been a lot, and the rate has been ticking up. Some of them have been enough to hurt too
As much as it would be ideal to land decisive blows, death by 1000 cuts is a feasible way to get companies in line
It’s like the straight of Hormuz - you don’t need to stop all the ships, you just need to damage enough of them to change the risk profile. If one megacorp falls because of privacy violations, then privacy violations become a financial risk. It will change the incentives for megacorps and their investors
We need to learn to take a win, even a small one. Because (unfortunately) that’s our only path forward. No glorious revolution is coming in our lifetimes, but we are gaining momentum.
We need to learn to celebrate wins, or we’ll all be too disengaged keep pushing when the opportunity window for transformative change opens up. We won’t know what it looks like
Go Italy, now the rest of EU should do the same, and maybe it will amount to enough money that it will make Meta pay attention?
0.47% times 27 EU states equals 12.69%. It’ll probably make them invest higher in lobbying. They won’t change behavior as that is core to their business.
Most EU states have far smaller populations than Italy, thus also far fewer Meta users/victims.
Even though I’m sorry to say I still have a Facebook account, it’s one of the few apps I just won’t install.
That’s wild that they thought that was ok.
Who said they thought it was ok? 😄
Good point, well made











